Beanie Feldstein
as Molly
Jessica Williams
as Miss Fine
Billie Lourd
as Gigi
Skyler Gisondo
as Jared
Diana Silvers
as Hope
Victoria Ruesga
as Ryan
Mason Gooding
as Nick
Eduardo Franco
as Theo
Nico Hiraga
as Tanner
Austin Crute
as Alan
Noah Galvin
as George
Mike O'Brien
as Pat the Pizza Guy
Ben Harris
as Yacht Waiter
Kyle Samples
as Butler
Deb Hiett
as George's Mom
Bluesy Burke
as Cindy
Christopher Avila
as Rob
Stephanie Styles
as Alison
John Hartman
as Yacht Waiter No. 2
Adam Krist
as Dick
Gideon Lang
as Skip
Ellen Doyle
as Murder Mystery Nurse